Great construction and solid boot. Fit and finish was excellent and this leather is absolutely gorgeous. This boot was exactly what I was looking for - top tier quality, unique leather and not a dress boot, but yet not a rugged boot. In person, these boots are just like the pictures - just beautiful. For sizing, I’m between 10 and 10.5 and almost an E width, so most of my shoes are 10.5 and a 10 in Thursday, Grant Stone and Iron Rangers. I’d say the Caswells are true to size, but 10.5 wasn’t available. I ordered the 10 and the toe box is a bit too narrow, but I just had to have this boot and don’t regret it. Can’t wait to see what comes out in the new line