I'm an 11D heel to toe, but 11.5C heel to ball. I tried an 11D in a different leather, but it was definitely too snug in the toes, so definitely be sure of your sizing - true to size is right, I think, but I also think they're a touch on the narrow side as the 11.5D works well for me. That said, they're well-made and quite comfortable. Can't complain at all once you get sizing down right!
I purchased these in 11D and the fit is true to size. They are so comfortable, even before full break-in, that I'm looking forward to my next pair of Caswell Boots. Stitching is flawless and I'm looking forward to building up my patina on these waxy commanders. Very satisfied current and future customer here!!
Perfectly welted. The brand was really responsive. The fit is true to size.